I was thinking the same thing about the crime scene, but now I'm not sure. With the crime scene investigation we could learn one of the killer's talents (potentially useful later, but won't catch anyone right now) or hangout location, but with the way people were spread out, knowing that there was a wolf in location X (or sulking) won't probably isn't that immediately helpful either. Meanwhile, checking alibis could potentially lead to finding someone who targeted Kraken. What are other people's thoughts on this?
That said, our current strategy might still be for the best, since we certainly don't have enough trusted people to check every alibi.
Do we know that you can't accidentally check your own alibi? If not, it might be best to investigate locations we weren't at.
Which in my case means Investigate the Gym.