When the options from story are the Salutory Alchemist (Villain) or the Concocter (technically also Villain)… yeah. Either Neutral or wolf. I’m not buying an Above Name there - especially not with mine already in play. Role-wise in a game, they bump; why have two on the same team?
I haven’t quite got a handle on your Name yet btw, Kraken (so no need to feel bad about missing my hints!). So far your initial logic from D1 is one of the reasons you’ve been townread, but I don’t want to proceed too much further without at least some intimation of a claim from you.
- - - Updated - - -
To be clear, that is not what I said. I said they are ‘probably not wolf’, because I thought they were Neutral and a Concocter.
Them claiming Alchemist instead throws it all off, and is making me increasingly suspicious.