Biggest surprise when you read the book...

[Rynjin]

I mean Niteowl is right there. There's someone who also does his best to fight for what is right, without being a volatile homophobe and racist, who doesn't die needlessly when he realizes sometimes there isn't much one man can do against someone as powerful as Veidt.

It's telling people don't go for him, the person we actually are in a situation like this, and instead devolve into Rorschach's screaming lunacy. This is what Moore is confused about- not that people aren't siding with Veidt, but that people are so willing to dehumanize into a creature of violence and anti-thought instead of recognizing themselves in the shlubby guy who was just too late.

Most people don't "identify" with Rorschach (though there are definitely some crazies out there) but it's hard not to sympathize with the guy who comes closest to making a difference and has principles he stands behind.

A man's convictions and efforts can be laudable without condoning all of his actions and beliefs. Refusing to bow to tyranny, even in the face of death, may not be SMART, but it is courageous.

Rorschach is given the option to either lend his tacit approval to an act of terror and the creation of a new shadow regime, or die. Niteowl chooses to either truly bend the knee and give up, or perhaps play the long game, it's left somewhat ambiguous. Both options are understandable. Neither are perfect.

Off topic: Love your new profile pic.