Oh, I see. My version is the 11th Doctor version, where under the Athletics skill (Gamemaster's Guide page 30) it says 'Dodging a blow is an Athletics rolls, but blocking a punch would use the Fighting skill (paired with Coordination)."

However, I also have a copy of the limited edition, which upon inspection lacks that language and backs up what you said under Learned Skills and Instinct (page 61 for that version). So it must have been updated. I guess that's on me for using an outdated rulebook to build my character—I'd definitely have put a point in Fighting if I realized this sooner. Never mind, I'll just modify my tactics in future confrontations. I'll take the unconsciousness, no point spending story points too early when Pavilion only has 6...