Regarding the remaining loot:

Quote Originally Posted by Farmerbink View Post
7 potions of cure serious wounds taking one
3 potions of lesser restoration party loot
a chime of opening Filburn is one of the scouts, so this makes sense
1 masterwork bucklers Filburn already has a MW Light Steel Shield
and a wand of daylight (24 charges) Daylight is on the Bard Spell List, so Filburn can take it
The potions are not effective in-combat healing - using them incurs attacks of opportunity and using them takes too many actions. Filburn can cast Cure Light Wounds, Aurora has Lay on Hands, Waylan isn't in melee but has healing spells, Elrembriel is not in melee (and we want to protect her if possible). This leaves only Morevek as a PC likely to need to use them that doesn't have much better chances.

Instead, I would advise us to consider them as out-of-combat healing (3d8+5 HPs healed has a decent chance of being enough to be worth it). This could allow Waylan to use more of this 3rd level spells (when we level up to 5) on offense instead of healing. Filburn will take one potion of Cure Serious Wounds, but the Potions of Restoration should be held as party-loot, IMO. Who wants to track the party loot on their sheet? Filburn has the strength to carry it all without issue..

Speaking of leveling up to 5...are we planning to level mid-dungeon (and ignoring the role-playing issues that could incur) or are we leveling up at another time? Is this a good time for such to happen?