https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8SIST9t72kY
In the vein of Tales of the Jedi, a new series of shorts is dropping on May the Fourth. Holy crap this looks good to me. Much better than Acolyte.
Printable View
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8SIST9t72kY
In the vein of Tales of the Jedi, a new series of shorts is dropping on May the Fourth. Holy crap this looks good to me. Much better than Acolyte.
It's kind of embarrassing how much the cartoons just run laps around the live action series. Ahsoka, Mandolorian and Book of Boba all would have gone up a letter grade if they looked this good
I'm very dubious that they can make Barriss make sense
When you don't have to deal with annoying things like sets, and actors...Quote:
Originally Posted by Errorname
If one can harness the tech that gives cinematics of the quality of the game Diablo III or IV (the cut scenes as but one example are very good, as are the intro and outro scenes for each act) why would you go for the lower grade stuff that was in these trailers?
This style was designed for producing an actual show on a TV budget and going for a photorealistic level of detail is very expensive and largely unnecessary, the style still works and looks good.Quote:
Originally Posted by KorvinStarmast
There's a fan animation - Battle of the Heroes that does the entire Anakin v. Obi-wan fight on Mustafar in Clone Wars style. It's superb.Quote:
Originally Posted by Errorname
Agreed. Seven years ago, SWTOR dropped the 'Betrayed' trailer for its Knights of the Eternal Throne expansion. And while it looks fantastic, it was also widely claimed to cost $1 million dollars per minute of footage. That might be justifiable when trying to hype up a game expansion that was, at the time, pulling in huge amounts of subscription money, but it doesn't work for TV, where it would cost something on the order of $20 million per episode.Quote:
Originally Posted by Errorname
The style used in TCW, which has received vast improvements over time as technology has advanced and the animators have gotten better at using it, is really quite ideal for making Star Wars content at a price point that makes sense.
Saw three episodes. Immediate thought: it's called "Tales of the Empire" and there's a story about the CIS and Dathomir witches. No Empire. I thought this was supposed to be Tales of The Empire?
Anyway, Grievous's ridiculous mustache-twirling villainy aside, writing seemed decent albeit butchered in delivery. It's like the voice actors *literally* phoned it in, the only reason I don't think that actually happened was the audio quality. But jeez, the voice acting reeks of unrehearsed first-takes only. Why the director would find this acceptable I have no idea.
Anyway. We actually get the Empire in episode 2, only for them to mostly disappear right back in episode 3. Why is this called "Tales of the Empire" and not "Tales of Morgan Elisbeth"?
Ridiculously poor title aside, it's actually better than I expected. Terrible delivery only lasted the first episode. Still, hopefully the second half will be more interesting - seems like they just focused on Ahsoka villain backstory in the first three.
I'd say the next two for you are pretty Empire focused, with the final one a bit Empire focused.Quote:
Originally Posted by Peelee
I'd tend to agree that Tales of Morgan and Tales of Barriss would have been better (and then they could have broken it in half to get two releases out of it, rather than dumping them altogether?
I will say, I was glad to see an attempt to make Dathomir not a monoculture, even if I'm not sure how other 'clans' works with what we see of Dathomir in other media (especially Fallen Order). I also really enjoyed how no one else on Dathomir knew why the droid army had come and so was, reasonably, afraid they'd be genocided too (which they may indeed have been) and Morgan's total unwillingness (or to be fair, lack of knowledge as she's clearly very junior) that this entire thing is happening because Mother Talzin deliberately double-crossed Dooku and is attempting to kill him.
We also don't see the army of the dead or any of the Nightbrothers, which is a shame, given how much I think poor Feral has been totally forgotten by Star Wars's desire to rehab Asajj.
Ok, so in retrospect, the show was pretty good. Not great, but decently good (biggest issues were the awful line delivery in episode 1 and the "I'm bad! Now I'm good! Now you're good!" whiplash in 4-6).Quote:
Originally Posted by ecarden
But i hate it as "Stories of the Empire". You hit the nail on the head with "stories of Morgan Elsbeth and Barris Offee". That's the real title. The Empire is practically an afterthought in the first three and little more than set dressing in the latter three. I still have the old Legends novel Tales from the Empire. Which actually had tales, and from the Empire! They even had a straight guide for this!
Only two episodes are worth being called Tales of the Empire I'd say. Episode 2 and episode 4 which were coincidentally the two that worked the best.
Also can we come up with a new Tale of the Empire other than bad lady Empire type becomes a goodie cause we've had that, what, three times in recent succession with this, the Obi-Wan show, and that canon videogame based on Operation Cinder.
Honestly I'm not too sure I liked Barriss's story. The last time we saw her she had totally gone off the deep end. She blew up the Jedi Temple, she framed Ahsoka, she attacked Asajj Ventress, fought (and quickly lost to) Anakin... Even if she was right about the Jedi Order, that they had fallen from the light they once held so dear, she hadn't merely fallen from the light - she had embraced the dark.
So for her half of Tales of the Empire to be about how she was actually still a nice person was just weird. I get that sixty minutes isn't a particularly long time to show her realising how far she had fallen herself and reverse course, but they really should have tried harder.
Like maybe Barriss finds Ahsoka, for example, and they fight but Ahsoka doesn't hate Barriss regardless of how much Barriss wants her to. Something like...
"Revenge is not the Jedi way."
"You are no Jedi!"
"Perhaps, but you still could be."
...then you get to see Barriss as she was in the third epiwode.
Maybe Darth Vader could have sensed weakness still in her or something, or at least said he remembered what happened which could give her a need to take the nearest exit as soon as bloody possible.
But no he was just on screen for maybe 20 seconds more than he was in the trailer. What a tease for absolutely nada.
Was weird how much they treated Bariss with kid gloves really given what we've heard and seen in regard to Inquisitor training before.
My reaction to the trailer for "History of an Empire" is complete skepticism. While the production quality seems decent enough, there are a few aspects that made me question the overall appeal of this film.
First of all, the trailer doesn't deliver a clear and compelling narrative. Instead, it offers a disjointed collection of scenes that jump from one character to another without any coherent thread tying them together. This lack of narrative coherence makes me wonder if the film itself suffers from a similar disjointed storyline.
Also, the acting shown in the trailer leaves a lot to be desired. The delivery seems lame and uninspired, lacking the depth and emotional resonance needed to truly engage an audience. Without compelling performances to anchor the story, it's hard to get invested in the characters or their journey.
Also, the visual effects presented in the trailer seem amateurish and dated. The visuals don't feel immersive or realistic, ranging from poorly rendered CGI to awkward green screen compositing. Instead, they serve as a distracting reminder of the film's limitations in terms of budget and production cost.